SYS-CON MEDIA Authors: Yeshim Deniz, Liz McMillan, Elizabeth White, Maria C. Horton, Andy Thurai

Blog Feed Post

To Flash or to Open Web

Nowadays, building [rich] Web applications can be quite challenging, as the proliferation of Web technologies has become overwhelming and confusing. The real challenge is that many interesting new Web technologies are being promoted by various groups, and it can be quite difficult for a developer or architect to filter the practical and future-proof ones from the cool and volatile ones.

As a rule of thumb, open technologies tend to be more pervasive and longer lasting (especially for the Internet) than proprietary technologies, which tend to bring more advanced capabilities early on. Consequently, Web application developers need to be pragmatically-open, by choosing open technologies whenever possible, but they should not hesitate to use proprietary ones when required. It is not about being religious about openness or anything else, but rather about being diligent so that one is able to choose the right technology to maximize the chances of success of the target application. In other words, it should not be a personal and emotional decision, but rather a business and rational one.

Today, for mainstream rich Web applications, there are two main technologies: Flash and Open Web (i.e., HTML, CSS, Ajax, SVG, etc…). While SilverLight and JavaFX are definitely interesting upcoming technologies, they are still unproven Web entities, and, for the sake of simplicity, this article will focus on Flash and Open Web.

Having worked for many years on the subject, and having spent time in both camps, I can honestly state that they both have their pros and cons and, depending on your rich Web application requirements, you might even need to use both. The trick to making a good business decisions is to have an objective look at each technology and to strip out all preconceived emotional opinions.

To help answer the question of what to use when, here is a technology-capability matrix, followed by short explanations.

 

SEO (Open Web)

While Google is making some good progress at indexing Flash content, SEO for Flash is still in its infancy, and, if your application depends on SEO to succeed, you better stick with well known URLs and HTML best practices. SEO is hard enough with regular page-based HTML content without adding unproven SEO-technologies to the mix. Even adding Ajax the wrong way could be extremely damaging to SEO. For example, the “#” URL trick that is used by many single-page Web applications might not be as SEO-friendly as it seems (Ajax and SEO will probably be the subject of a future post).

Mobile Web (Open Web)

Mobile Web is another place where Flash is still behind. Although Adobe is making  promising progress in this area, if your are not building a 2D game or  video/media centric application, there are very few reasons to encumber the overhead and uncertainty of another virtual machine on top of the already very capable modern mobile Web browsers. Nowadays, most of the new high-end devices have desktop-like browser capabilities (often based on WebKit) which allow developers to take full advantage of Open Web technologies such as Ajax and CSS 2.1+. Consequently, the best way to maximize your mobile application reach is to stick with Open Web technologies and architect your Web user interface in such a way that it progressively degrades for simpler mobile browsers. Alternatively, developers can to take advantage of the current mobile app stores trend that promotes device specific applications, but this is outside the Web scope of this article.

Rich HTML Display & Editing (Open Web)

While Flash 10 has some technologies which ease the development of HTML layout and editing components, it is still nowhere near the browser’s native capabilities. It is probably a fair guess that Flash 11 will have even better HTML capabilities, perhaps even embedding WebKit, but, for today, if you want to display and edit rich HTML, not surprisingly, the Web browser is your best friend.

On-Demand Performance (Open Web)

On-demand performance is the experience a user gets when accessing a Web application for the first time (i.e., when none of the application assets are in the browser’s cache). The common expectation for consumer Web applications is usually sub-second responsiveness. As outlined in a previous post about Compiled vs. Interpreted Web, the interpreted nature of the Web makes it very efficient for executing on-demand content & interaction, whereas the compiled nature of the Flash application model is more optimized for post-load execution. So, for applications requiring Web-fast first-time interaction experiences, the Open Web model is the best one.

Post-Load Performance (Flash)

Conversely, the compiled approach of Flash and frameworks such as Flex makes it much more optimized for post-load interactions. So, if you do not mind having a “loading-bar” on your application and have a very high logic execution performance requirement, then Flash might be a good solution. Note that new JavaScript VM such as Google Chrome V8 and Mozilla Firefox SpiderMonkey with TraceMonkey are really breaking the barrier of interpreted language performance. Unfortunately, Microsoft Internet Explorer is still behind (even IE 8) in terms of JavaScript execution speed. While we may suspect that Microsoft is going to work on optimizing their JavaScript engine soon, for now, the best way to have high execution logic performance across browsers is with Flash ActionScript 3.

Animation (Flash)

If you want to make pixel flies, then Flash is your best friend. While this statement is still true today, it is also important to note that, with modern browsers (including IE-8-) and Ajax toolkits such as jQuery, applications have access to some decent sets of animation capabilities using 100% Open Web technologies. So, unless animation is a cornerstone of your application, animation alone should not be a critical or decisive factor one way or  the other.

2D & 3D (Flash)

This is definitely a stronger one in favor of Flash. While Open Web is promoting some 2D standards and implementations (e.g., Canvas and SVG), nothing beats Flash performance and capabilities in reference to pixel and vector graphic creation and manipulation. While Canvas and some SVG are pretty well supported by Firefox and WebKit based browsers (i.e., Safari and Google Chrome), Microsoft IE is still not implementing those. Developers can circumvent this Microsoft limitation by using compatibilities such as JavaScript or even Flash libraries, but this usually comes at the cost of features and performance. In other words, while it is possible to do an online Photoshop or Visio-like applications in SVG/Canvas/VML, the investment required to do it with flash technology is definitely worthwhile. Unfortunately, Flash does not support the interpreted model, so Web developers will have to fully jump into the Flash development model and tools, which can be relatively high barriers of entry, especially for small visual components (e.g., Charting). There are some interesting Flash SVG libraries (e.g., sgweb) which allow Web developers to use Flash as an SVG renderer, but the lack of “AS3 eval support” is a strong limiting factor.

File handling (Flash)

File handling has always been completely left-out by the different Open Web standardization and implementer groups. Building an effective experience for accessing local files through a Web browser has always been challenging, to say the least. Even the most modern browsers still have the 1995 simple file-input component which allows for the selection of only one file at a time. Flash, while far from being perfect, does add some nice features in terms of this realm, such as multiple file selections and, more importantly, a way to read selected files of clients before sending them to the server. Unfortunately, enterprise Web applications would really benefit from file drag & drop support from and to the desktop (and File Explorer), but, somehow, this feature is always given a very low priority by the various decision makers (or is somehow labeled as a security hazard). Alternatively, you can use Java technology, as does Facebook for their photo uploader, which gives almost complete file-system control for signed applets (note: somehow, it feels kind of strange to write the word “applet” in 2009). Advanced clipboard support is also another neglected requirement.

Video & Audio Playback (Flash)

Two of HTML 5’s big new features, besides off-line support, are the video and audio tags. However, there still lot of discussion about the support format of video tags. One of the biggest issues is that the best video formats are not royalty free, and, while commercial vendors such as Adobe, Microsoft, and Google are willing to pay the video tax for their users, the open source community finds itself in a catch-22 situation. So, from an application developer standpoint, Flash is by far the best option to bring high quality video and audio to your application. With the latest support of H.264/mp4 video support of Flash, there is no good reason to really look elsewhere for now.

Video & Audio Recording (Flash)

I am splitting out media playback from recordings because, if they are not split, the later tends to be forgotten. It’s difficult to believe, but, in the 2-way Web era, the big promoters of Open Web technologies have no implementations or plans to support Web Video and Audio recording and uploading. Luckily, Adobe Flash has a pretty mature solution to this need, and while they have not opened the code, they have opened the APIs and protocols to allow developers to freely use the Flash player as a video recording device (see Red5 for an open source alternative to Adobe Flash Media server).

 

So, as can be seen, there is no one size fits all technology. It depends on the application requirements you might need to use multiple technology sets. Obviously, as a technology vendor or promoter your goal is to build and promote your technology for as many scenarios as possible, however, as an application developer, your only goal should be to ensure the success of your application, no matter the technology you end up using or switching to. Developers should rationally and objectively evaluate each of the technologies before investing too much time and money in any one of them. Also, avoiding over-hyped terms such as RIA and Social Network when defining application requirements will go a long way to help in terms of focusing on what really matters to users.

If you liked this article, a +1 on HN and/or a re-tweet are greatly appreciated.  

If you are in the midst of choosing your technologies for your next rich Web application, do not hesitate to contact me at [email protected]. (I provide everything from free advice to complete rich Web architecture and strategy consulting and services.)

Read the original blog entry...

More Stories By Jeremy Chone

Jeremy Chone is chief technology officer (CTO) and vice president of development and operations at iJuris, an innovative startup offering a rich Web application for lawyer collaboration and document assembly. In his role as CTO and vice president of development and operations, Jeremy is responsible for overseeing the company’s strategic direction for the iJuris service and technology as well as managing the service architecture, development, and operations.

Chone has more than 10 years of technical and business experience in major software companies such as Netscape, Oracle and Adobe where he has successfully aligned technology visions with business opportunities that deliver tangible results. In addition to a combination of technical and business acumen, Jeremy also possesses an in-depth knowledge of Rich Internet Application technologies, as well as holding many patents in the mobile and enterprise collaboration areas.

See Jeremy Chone's full biography

Latest Stories
The platform combines the strengths of Singtel's extensive, intelligent network capabilities with Microsoft's cloud expertise to create a unique solution that sets new standards for IoT applications," said Mr Diomedes Kastanis, Head of IoT at Singtel. "Our solution provides speed, transparency and flexibility, paving the way for a more pervasive use of IoT to accelerate enterprises' digitalisation efforts. AI-powered intelligent connectivity over Microsoft Azure will be the fastest connected pat...
Sold by Nutanix, Nutanix Mine with Veeam can be deployed in minutes and simplifies the full lifecycle of data backup operations, including on-going management, scaling and troubleshooting. The offering combines highly-efficient storage working in concert with Veeam Backup and Replication, helping customers achieve comprehensive data protection for all their workloads — virtual, physical and private cloud —to meet increasing business demands for uptime and productivity.
CloudEXPO has been the M&A capital for Cloud companies for more than a decade with memorable acquisition news stories which came out of CloudEXPO expo floor. DevOpsSUMMIT New York faculty member Greg Bledsoe shared his views on IBM's Red Hat acquisition live from NASDAQ floor. Acquisition news was announced during CloudEXPO New York which took place November 12-13, 2019 in New York City.
Blockchain has shifted from hype to reality across many industries including Financial Services, Supply Chain, Retail, Healthcare and Government. While traditional tech and crypto organizations are generally male dominated, women have embraced blockchain technology from its inception. This is no more evident than at companies where women occupy many of the blockchain roles and leadership positions. Join this panel to hear three women in blockchain share their experience and their POV on the futu...
"At the keynote this morning we spoke about the value proposition of Nutanix, of having a DevOps culture and a mindset, and the business outcomes of achieving agility and scale, which everybody here is trying to accomplish," noted Mark Lavi, DevOps Solution Architect at Nutanix, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at @DevOpsSummit at 20th Cloud Expo, held June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY.
BMC has unmatched experience in IT management, supporting 92 of the Forbes Global 100, and earning recognition as an ITSM Gartner Magic Quadrant Leader for five years running. Our solutions offer speed, agility, and efficiency to tackle business challenges in the areas of service management, automation, operations, and the mainframe.
As you know, enterprise IT conversation over the past year have often centered upon the open-source Kubernetes container orchestration system. In fact, Kubernetes has emerged as the key technology -- and even primary platform -- of cloud migrations for a wide variety of organizations. Kubernetes is critical to forward-looking enterprises that continue to push their IT infrastructures toward maximum functionality, scalability, and flexibility. As they do so, IT professionals are also embr...
Docker and Kubernetes are key elements of modern cloud native deployment automations. After building your microservices, common practice is to create docker images and create YAML files to automate the deployment with Docker and Kubernetes. Writing these YAMLs, Dockerfile descriptors are really painful and error prone.Ballerina is a new cloud-native programing language which understands the architecture around it - the compiler is environment aware of microservices directly deployable into infra...
Apptio fuels digital business transformation. Technology leaders use Apptio's machine learning to analyze and plan their technology spend so they can invest in products that increase the speed of business and deliver innovation. With Apptio, they translate raw costs, utilization, and billing data into business-centric views that help their organization optimize spending, plan strategically, and drive digital strategy that funds growth of the business. Technology leaders can gather instant recomm...
In an age of borderless networks, security for the cloud and security for the corporate network can no longer be separated. Security teams are now presented with the challenge of monitoring and controlling access to these cloud environments, at the same time that developers quickly spin up new cloud instances and executives push forwards new initiatives. The vulnerabilities created by migration to the cloud, such as misconfigurations and compromised credentials, require that security teams t...
Serverless Architecture is the new paradigm shift in cloud application development. It has potential to take the fundamental benefit of cloud platform leverage to another level. "Focus on your application code, not the infrastructure" All the leading cloud platform provide services to implement Serverless architecture : AWS Lambda, Azure Functions, Google Cloud Functions, IBM Openwhisk, Oracle Fn Project.
AI and machine learning disruption for Enterprises started happening in the areas such as IT operations management (ITOPs) and Cloud management and SaaS apps. In 2019 CIOs will see disruptive solutions for Cloud & Devops, AI/ML driven IT Ops and Cloud Ops. Customers want AI-driven multi-cloud operations for monitoring, detection, prevention of disruptions. Disruptions cause revenue loss, unhappy users, impacts brand reputation etc.
DevOps is often described as a combination of technology and culture. Without both, DevOps isn't complete. However, applying the culture to outdated technology is a recipe for disaster; as response times grow and connections between teams are delayed by technology, the culture will die. A Nutanix Enterprise Cloud has many benefits that provide the needed base for a true DevOps paradigm. In their Day 3 Keynote at 20th Cloud Expo, Chris Brown, a Solutions Marketing Manager at Nutanix, and Mark Lav...
Serverless Computing or Functions as a Service (FaaS) is gaining momentum. Amazon is fueling the innovation by expanding Lambda to edge devices and content distribution network. IBM, Microsoft, and Google have their own FaaS offerings in the public cloud. There are over half-a-dozen open source serverless projects that are getting the attention of developers.
As you know, enterprise IT conversation over the past year have often centered upon the open-source Kubernetes container orchestration system. In fact, Kubernetes has emerged as the key technology -- and even primary platform -- of cloud migrations for a wide variety of organizations. Kubernetes is critical to forward-looking enterprises that continue to push their IT infrastructures toward maximum functionality, scalability, and flexibility. As they do so, IT professionals are also embr...