SYS-CON MEDIA Authors: Pat Romanski, Elizabeth White, Liz McMillan, Zakia Bouachraoui, Yeshim Deniz

Blog Feed Post

Public Cloud Core Banking: Vendors Hype or Short term Reality?

Many large banks are IBM Mainframes users. They use mainframes for decades. They use other platforms as well, but their Core Banking systems are deployed on Mainframes.

Recently leading Cloud Computing vendors such as Amazon, Microsoft and Google approached large banks in order to start migration of systems to their Public Clouds. 

I looked for evidence supporting the notion that Banks are transforming from Mainframes to Public Clouds. I found no evidence.

I am not the one to be blamed for not finding any significant evidence, because there is no evidence supporting the notion cited above. 

Banks are using Public Clouds but...
Like many other organizations, banks are using Public Clouds applications. However, they do not use it for Core Banking systems deployment.
They use Public Clouds for applications which are less integrated with the Core Banking systems.

If they will not use Public Clouds for Core Systems, IBM Mainframes will be used for many years.

Public Clouds, Private Clouds or Hybrid Clouds
The answer to the question: Which type of Clouds are you using or you will use in the next years? will  vary.  
SMBs' frequent answer would be: Public Clouds
Large Enterprises' frequent answer would be: Hybrid Clouds.

Hybrid Clouds usage is based upon both Private Clouds and Public Clouds.

If you read a previous post titled: The Next generation of Private Clouds, you probably noticed that, according to Forrester Consulting's survey, building Private Clouds is a priority for nearly half of the large enterprises surveyed.

You may also noticed that 67% of the survey respondents said that access to Mainframe Data was critically important or very important in Clouds environments. 

Conclusions

1. Large enterprises will continue to use Mainframes.

2. Large Enterprises will use Hybrid and Private Clouds. Mainframes will be part of Private Clouds.

Large Banks will not migrate of Mainframes to other platforms if they considering including Mainframes in their Private Clouds. 

Business Barriers to Migration from Mainframes
Is there a Business Case for migrating Core Banking systems from Mainframe? 
It is difficult to justify such a large and expensive  endeavour.

The CEO or another manager would ask: What would we get for this multi year expensive endeavour?
The answer would probably be the same functionality.

Not the best answer for convincing Business oriented non-tech managers to spend a large amount of money.

Risks

1. resistance to change
Many of the current elderly Mainframe team members will not be able to adjust to new platforms and new development paradigm and tools. They are afraid of losing their jobs. 
Some of them will resist the change and will not cooperate.

2. losing expertize
The IT staff maintaining current Core Banking systems has limitations, as far as new technologies and architectures are concerned, however some of the employees have deep understanding of current systems and the Bank's Business processes and Business goals.

They also know a lot about the Organizational Culture and about people working in the Business departments. 

Many of these employees will retire or will be fired.
The new young energetic employees, replacing them,  lack understanding and knowledge of the Business, the Organization and the People.     

3. Bugs 
Even in case of no resistance to change do not expect 100% accurate migration.
New bugs introduced to the new system imply cost and less satisfied customers.    

3. missing Functionality
Undocumented functionality will not be part of the new Core Banking Systems.
The assumption that the documentation of complex old systems is full and accurate is an unrealistic assumption

4. missing Data
Replace the word Functionality in the previous section by Data. Do not expect 100% precise data migration. 

5. Misinterpreted Business Processes
The Challenges to BPM implementations include lack of Visibility and non-documented processes. 
If the Bank migrating from Mainframe, did not complete its BPM implementation, some Business Processes in the new non-mainframe systems will not be identical to current Business  

6. Co-existence and Migration process
After completion the development of new systems, these systems should be deployed.
Anything could get wrong during the actual migration process.

  
Additional Challenges 
  
 1. Security
Mainframes Security is better than other platforms Security.
In addition to the gap between Mainframe Security and Windows Security and Linux Security in non Cloud based environment, there is an issue of Public Cloud Security.

I am not sure that in house Linux and Windows based systems are more secured than Public Cloud based Linux and Windows systems. 
However, customers perceive them as less secure because they are managed by employees of another company and because their systems shared resources with other enterprises' systems.

Systems and Data Security is more important to banks than to many other enterprises. 

2. processing Large Amounts of Data
Mainframes are capable of processing large amounts of Data. High percentage of Business Data resides on Mainframes. 

3. Scalability and Workloads Management 
Current Public Clouds are based on Hypervisiors, Windows and Linux. 
Are these Operating Systems capable of supporting large amount of concurrent Banking Transactions? 
I doubt. My experience, as well as others experience, do not support the assumption that these Operating Systems will be capable of supporting and managing  properly large number of concurrent Banking transactions.  

Reasons to replace current mainframe Core Banking systems


1. Maintenance
Maintenance of old Legacy systems could be a nightmare. 

Many of the people we wrote the programs 20 years or 30 years ago are not available.

The systems are not architectured well and are not structured properly. Usually the systems are large monolithic silos.

The code was changed many times by many different people.

2. lack of Agility and a long Change Backlog  
The lack of Agility is an additional maintenance difficulty.
The Business result of the difficulty to change systems is a long list of unfulfilled change requests.
 
3. Skills unavailability
Young professional prefer to work with mainstream technologies and/or new innovative technologies. Gradual skills decline is a real problem in Mainframes environment.

Are there non-migration alternatives?
Basically there are two alternatives addressing Mainframes concerns without risky migration to other platforms:

1. Modernization
Systems modernization could be performed without migration.
The Modernized systems could be Service Oriented and may use advanced modern technologies, which are available on Mainframes.

It is not a Big Bang risky approach but it is still a long journey. Those who will decide to modernize  their Mainframe Core Banking systems will use Mainframes for more than Short Term period.
However, after completing systems Modernization they will be capable of gradual and relatively smooth migration, if they will decide to migrate.  

2. Core Banking Packages
Core Banking systems could be replaced by Core Banking packages. These packages resemble ERP products. Some of these packages can be deployed on Mainframes and on other platforms as well.

An endeavour of choosing a Core Banking Package and replacing current Core Banking Systems by it is also a long journey. Usually it is a longer journey than Modernization.

After completing the journey maintenance could be easier and cheaper, the dependency on employees is reduced and future gradual or complete migration from Mainframe is smoother and cheaper.  

Migrated from Mainframe but not the Public Cloud
After long journeys to Modernization or Core Banking packages the last thing you would think of is another migration from Mainframes to another platform.
  
Few years later you may start migration to another platform. Even if someone will migrate to Linux or Windows the systems are still deployed in his Private Cloud (or not in any Cloud).

There are still significant barriers to Public Cloud based deployment.
I will name few major barriers: Local Regulation, International Regulation (e.g. Basel 3), Security and integration with other systems in the Data Center and in other Public Clouds.  

   
Real World Case Studies? - Capital One
Amazon's leading Early Adopter is Capital One.  
Capital One is a Credit Cards company and a Large Bank. 

Capital Bank is using Open Source software, Microservices and Devops. Capital is performing transformation to Digital Banking. 

Capital Bank's CIO Rob Alexander presented a Keynote presentation in last October at Amazon's re:Invent conference.  

Alexander described how they start experimenting AWS in 2014 and how late in 2015, they launched production Mobile Banking applications based on Amazon's AWS.

I guess that the Mobile applications are using Mainframe Core Banking Applications and Data.

According to Capital One's CIO "the bank has been working closely with Amazon's team to develop the Security model". 

For more details read: 
AWS Case Study: Capital One 
AWS reinvent 2015 keynote - Rob Alexander


The private Security model will be only the first step in a long process of development of industry Security standards and implementing these standards.


Me Bank
Me bank is a full fledged retail bank. The Melbourne-Headquartered company manages 20 billion $ in assets and has 800 employees who support 280,000 customers around Australia. 

Amazon AWS is used for Development and Testing.
The Core Banking systems reside in the bank's Data Center.     
For more details read:
AWS Case Study: ME Bank


ME Bank is not a large bank. I do not know if the Core Banking Systems were deployed on Mainframes.
If they were, I would not predict migration from Mainframe in the following 5 years.

Microsoft's partner: Capgemini
Capgemini partnered with Microsoft in order to provide Cloud based Services in Microsoft's Azure

I did not find Case Studies in Capgemini's white paper Cloud Computing In Banking.

However, I found the following text: " Banks are expected to enter the cloud computing arena cautiously, with no single cloud services delivery model being a silver bullet for best meeting their demanding business needs". 

Capgemini's white paper also discussing the first methodological step of choosing the right cloud model. The models are: SaaS, PaaS, IaaS and BPaaS (Business Process as a Service). 

Microsoft's partner is preparing the methodology for banks entering the Cloud Computing arena. No Case Studies yet.

It should be remembered that the first banks that will  use Azure will be smaller banks using Windows operating system and not Mainframe based large banks. 


The Bottom Line
Mainframe was not dead in the 90ies and was not dead few years ago.
Large Banks will continue Core Banking systems deployment on Mainframes at least for the following 5 years. 

Read the original blog entry...

More Stories By Avi Rosenthal

Ari has over 30 years of experience in IT across a wide variety of technology platforms, including application development, technology selection, application and infrastructure strategies, system design, middleware and transaction management technologies and security.

Positions held include CTO for one of the largest software houses in Israel as well as the CTO position for one of the largest ministries of the Israeli government.

Latest Stories
SAP is the world leader in enterprise applications in terms of software and software-related service revenue. Based on market capitalization, we are the world's third largest independent software manufacturer. Harness the power of your data and accelerate trusted outcome-driven innovation by developing intelligent and live solutions for real-time decisions and actions on a single data copy. Support next-generation transactional and analytical processing with a broad set of advanced analytics - r...
When building large, cloud-based applications that operate at a high scale, it’s important to maintain a high availability and resilience to failures. In order to do that, you must be tolerant of failures, even in light of failures in other areas of your application. “Fly two mistakes high” is an old adage in the radio control airplane hobby. It means, fly high enough so that if you make a mistake, you can continue flying with room to still make mistakes. In his session at 18th Cloud Expo, Lee A...
Founded in 2002 and headquartered in Chicago, Nexum® takes a comprehensive approach to security. Nexum approaches business with one simple statement: “Do what’s right for the customer and success will follow.” Nexum helps you mitigate risks, protect your data, increase business continuity and meet your unique business objectives by: Detecting and preventing network threats, intrusions and disruptions Equipping you with the information, tools, training and resources you need to effectively m...
The vast majority of businesses now use cloud services, yet many still struggle with realizing the full potential of their IT investments. In particular, small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) lack the internal IT staff and expertise to fully move to and manage workloads in public cloud environments. Speaker Todd Schwartz will help session attendees better navigate the complex cloud market and maximize their technical investments. The SkyKick co-founder and co-CEO will share the biggest challe...
Despite being the market leader, we recognized the need to transform and reinvent our business at Dynatrace, before someone else disrupted the market. Over the course of three years, we changed everything - our technology, our culture and our brand image. In this session we'll discuss how we navigated through our own innovator's dilemma, and share takeaways from our experience that you can apply to your own organization.
All in Mobile is a mobile app agency that helps enterprise companies and next generation startups build the future of digital. We offer mobile development and design for smartphones, tablets and wearables. Our projects cover the latest and most innovative technologies - voice assistants, AI, AR/VR and more. We excel at solutions for sports, fintech and retail industries.
In his general session at 19th Cloud Expo, Manish Dixit, VP of Product and Engineering at Dice, discussed how Dice leverages data insights and tools to help both tech professionals and recruiters better understand how skills relate to each other and which skills are in high demand using interactive visualizations and salary indicator tools to maximize earning potential. Manish Dixit is VP of Product and Engineering at Dice. As the leader of the Product, Engineering and Data Sciences team at D...
Nutanix has been named "Platinum Sponsor" of CloudEXPO | DevOpsSUMMIT | DXWorldEXPO New York, which will take place November 12-13, 2018 in New York City. Nutanix makes infrastructure invisible, elevating IT to focus on the applications and services that power their business. The Nutanix Enterprise Cloud Platform blends web-scale engineering and consumer-grade design to natively converge server, storage, virtualization and networking into a resilient, software-defined solution with rich machine ...
ICC is a computer systems integrator and server manufacturing company focused on developing products and product appliances to meet a wide range of computational needs for many industries. Their solutions provide benefits across many environments, such as datacenter deployment, HPC, workstations, storage networks and standalone server installations. ICC has been in business for over 23 years and their phenomenal range of clients include multinational corporations, universities, and small busines...
"DevOps is set to be one of the most profound disruptions to hit IT in decades," said Andi Mann. "It is a natural extension of cloud computing, and I have seen both firsthand and in independent research the fantastic results DevOps delivers. So I am excited to help the great team at @DevOpsSUMMIT and CloudEXPO tell the world how they can leverage this emerging disruptive trend."
DXWorldEXPO LLC announced today that Nutanix has been named "Platinum Sponsor" of CloudEXPO | DevOpsSUMMIT | DXWorldEXPO New York, which will take place November 12-13, 2018 in New York City. Nutanix makes infrastructure invisible, elevating IT to focus on the applications and services that power their business. The Nutanix Enterprise Cloud Platform blends web-scale engineering and consumer-grade design to natively converge server, storage, virtualization and networking into a resilient, softwar...
Digital transformation is about embracing digital technologies into a company's culture to better connect with its customers, automate processes, create better tools, enter new markets, etc. Such a transformation requires continuous orchestration across teams and an environment based on open collaboration and daily experiments. In his session at 21st Cloud Expo, Alex Casalboni, Technical (Cloud) Evangelist at Cloud Academy, explored and discussed the most urgent unsolved challenges to achieve fu...
Wasabi is the hot cloud storage company delivering low-cost, fast, and reliable cloud storage. Wasabi is 80% cheaper and 6x faster than Amazon S3, with 100% data immutability protection and no data egress fees. Created by Carbonite co-founders and cloud storage pioneers David Friend and Jeff Flowers, Wasabi is on a mission to commoditize the storage industry. Wasabi is a privately held company based in Boston, MA. Follow and connect with Wasabi on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and the Wasabi blog...
Lori MacVittie is a subject matter expert on emerging technology responsible for outbound evangelism across F5's entire product suite. MacVittie has extensive development and technical architecture experience in both high-tech and enterprise organizations, in addition to network and systems administration expertise. Prior to joining F5, MacVittie was an award-winning technology editor at Network Computing Magazine where she evaluated and tested application-focused technologies including app secu...
CloudEXPO | DevOpsSUMMIT | DXWorldEXPO Silicon Valley 2019 will cover all of these tools, with the most comprehensive program and with 222 rockstar speakers throughout our industry presenting 22 Keynotes and General Sessions, 250 Breakout Sessions along 10 Tracks, as well as our signature Power Panels. Our Expo Floor will bring together the leading global 200 companies throughout the world of Cloud Computing, DevOps, IoT, Smart Cities, FinTech, Digital Transformation, and all they entail. As ...